Before we dive into the details, a quick reminder of how the tie-breakers work:

• Points
• Win Percentage
• Head to Head results (win-loss-draw)
• Head to Head quota results (who won by the most amount in matchups)
• Division Record
• Season Quota performance
• Coin flip

Now that the IT Nerd has some time on his hands, let’s take a deep dive on what the playoff picture looks like for each of the flights.

Flight 1

The Flight 1 playoffs are set. With a pre-played match between DJ and Merritt happening on Tuesday and TJ and Mike Carroll playing before the rain came on Thursday, the seedings are set for Flight 1:

(#1) Mike Carroll vs. (#4) Merritt Daniels

(#2) Steve Donegan vs. (#3) Dan Kane

Flight 2

Assured Playoffs: Paul Daniels (Could be any seed) – If he loses and all others win, he would be surpassed by Morgan, Denny, Ed Van Slyke and be tied with Keeley on 27 pts and a 9-7-0 record. Paul beat Dan in their Week 1 matchup, this giving him the tiebreak.

In Contention: Ed Van Slyke, Jim Morgan, Denny Welch, Dan Keeley, Sean Mott

There are A LOT of scenarios that can play out as a result of this. The match to watch is the Jim Morgan-Sean Mott match. Sean Mott has an outside chance, but he must first beat Jim Morgan and then have other results go his way.

Flight 3

Assured Playoffs: Marty Donegan, Flight 3 #1 Seed. Jon Carroll, Seeding TBD

In Contention: Joe Donegan, Tom Donegan, Mike Mahar, Mike Costello

A simple win by Joe would lock down Flight 3, Division 2 (#2 seed), but a draw or loss opens things up for Tom Donegan, Mike Mahar to take the division with a win.

Should be an exciting week to end the 2023 regular season!

With all make-ups closed at the end of play on Week 15, the playoff picture is taking shape! Standings page is up to date.

The Flight 1 playoff picture is set, but the seeding is still up in the air: Mike Carroll, Dan Kane, Steve Donegan and Merritt Daniels will be moving on. All that’s left to be seen in Week 16 is what seeds they are.

Flight 2 playoff picture is a bit more crowded. There are 6 golfers who all have a chance of making playoffs – Ed Van Slyke, Dan Keeley, Paul Daniels, Jim Morgan, Denny Welch, Sean Mott.

Flight 3 is even more packed with 7 golfers within reach of playoffs. This flight has some prime time matchups for Week 16:

• Marty vs. Jon Carroll – Winner takes the #1 seed in Flight 3. A draw would guarantee them both playoffs, with Marty being #1 seed
• Bill Kirkby vs. Mike Costello – Can Mike pull out a win and have other matches break his way and backdoor a way into the playoffs?
• Mike Mahar vs Tom Donegan – A win by either of them can vault them into division title (with Joe Donegan loss, tie) or highly increase chances to make playoffs
• Brian Thayer vs. Rob Manipole – A serious outside contender in Brian Thayer needs a win and other matches to be draws, losses
• Joe Donegan vs. Bob Moran – Joe can lock up the division with a win, but a draw and other matches breaking his way would still see him in the playoffs.

Should be an interesting night to say the least!

Flight 1			Flight 3
Devin Carrigan	PAR#9	$             18	John Mooney	PAR#6	$                  9
Connor Brown		$              –	Mike Burns		$                   –
Dan Kane		$              –	Marty Donegan		$                   –
Pat Donahue		$              –	Jon Carroll	PAR#1BIR#2	$                18
Mike Carroll		$              –	Bill Kirkby		$                   –
TJ Donegan		$              –	Mike Costello		$                   –
Merritt Daniels		$              –	Rob Manipole		$                   –
DJ Mahar	BIR#1	$             18	Brian Thayer		$                   –
Steve Donegan		$              –	Mike Mahar		$                   –
Dick Donegan		$              –	Tom Donegan	PAR#4	$                  9
Craig Hawkinson		$              –	Bob Moran		$                   –
Matt Lochner		$              –	Joe Donegan		$                   –
Flight 2
Ed Van Slyke		$              –	Sean Mott		$                   –
Drew Prucha	BIR#7	$             12	Jim Morgan	BIR#4	$                12
Rick Fanto		$              –	Denny Welch		$                   –
Chris Donegan		$              –	Mike Shanahan		$                   –
Dale Russell		$              –	Dan Mahar		$                   –
Dan Keeley		$              –	Paul Daniels	PAR#9	$                12

Connor Brown Skin Pool:

Devin Carrigan		$             –
Connor Brown		$             –
Dan Kane		$             –
Pat Donahue		$             –
TJ Donegan	BIR#5	$            32
Merritt Daniels		$             –
DJ Mahar	BIR#1	$            32
Steve Donegan		$             –
Dick Donegan		$             –
Dale Russell		$             –
Dan Keeley		$             –
Paul Daniels		$             –
Mike Burns		$             –

		Week 16
Dan Kane	15	VS	13	Pat Donahue
Connor Brown	16	VS	16	Devin Carrigan
Mike Carroll	15	VS	11	TJ Donegan
Steve Donegan	11	VS	12	Dick Donegan
DJ Mahar	13	VS	13	Merritt Daniels
Craig Hawkinson	12	VS	13	Matt Lochner
Rick Fanto	11	VS	12	Chris Donegan
Drew Prucha	12	VS	11	Ed Van Slyke
Dale Russell	9	VS	12	Dan Keeley
Denny Welch	9	VS	11	Mike Shanahan
Jim Morgan	9	VS	11	Sean Mott
Dan Mahar	11	VS	11	Paul Daniels
Marty Donegan	8	VS	12	Jon Carroll
Mike Burns	7	VS	8	John Mooney
Bill Kirkby	6	VS	7	Mike Costello
Mike Mahar	4	VS	5	Tom Donegan
Brian Thayer	8	VS	1	Rob Manipole
Bob Moran	8	VS	9	Joe Donegan

Wk 15	Hole	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	Gross	Differential
Par		5	4	5	4	4	3	4	3	4
Dan Mahar	10	5	4	6	6	3	4	4	3	5	40	5
Mike Shanahan	10	6	5	6	4	4	4	6	3	5	43	1
Matt Lochner	12	7	4	7	3	5	3	5	4	5	43	0
DJ Mahar	13	5	5	6	5	4	4	5	4	5	43	-2
Dick Donegan	12	8	4	5	4	5	3	6	4	7	46	-2
Craig Hawkinson	11	6	5	6	5	5	4	4	3	5	43	0
Rob Manipole	2	8	6	10	6	7	5	6	5	7	60	-3
Mike Mahar	4	9	5	9	5	6	5	3	4	8	54	2
Jon Carroll	11	5	3	6	5	5	4	3	3	5	39	6
Bill Kirkby	7	8	5	9	5	6	5	4	4	8	54	-3
Merritt Daniels	13	6	4	6	4	5	3	5	3	5	41	0
Steve Donegan	11	6	4	6	5	5	3	5	4	7	45	-1
Ed Van Slyke	12	6	6	6	5	5	4	5	4	7	48	-5
Rick Fanto	11	5	4	7	7	6	3	4	3	5	44	0
Tom Donegan	6	6	5	7	4	6	5	6	5	6	50	-2
Gary Thompson	7	7	5	8	5	6	5	6	4	6	52	-4
Paul Daniels	11	7	5	7	5	4	4	4	4	4	44	-1
Jim Morgan	10	6	5	6	3	7	4	5	4	7	47	0
Joe Donegan	9	6	5	7	5	5	4	6	3	5	46	-1
Brian Thayer	8	6	5	7	5	5	4	6	4	5	47	-1
John Mooney	9	7	4	6	5	4	3	5	4	6	44	1
Marty Donegan	8	9	4	8	5	5	4	4	3	5	47	2
Mike Costello	7	6	4	9	6	6	4	6	5	5	51	-2
Mike Burns	9	9	9	6	9	4	6	4	5	5	7	-6
Dan Keeley	12	7	4	6	5	4	3	4	3	6	42	0
Drew Prucha	12	7	5	7	4	4	4	3	5	8	47	-3
Chris Donegan	11	5	4	6	5	5	4	4	3	5	41	2
Dale Russell	10	7	4	8	6	5	4	6	3	5	48	-3
Sean Mott	11	7	4	7	6	5	3	4	5	7	48	-4
Denny Welch	9	6	5	7	5	6	4	4	4	5	46	-1
TJ Donegan	12	7	4	6	5	3	4	4	3	6	42	1
Connor Brown	17	5	3	5	6	4	5	4	3	5	40	-2
Devin Carrigan	16	5	4	7	4	5	3	4	3	4	39	-1
Dan Kane	14	6	3	6	4	5	3	4	3	5	39	2
Mike Carroll	15	5	4	7	5	3	4	5	3	6	42	-2
Pat Donahue	0										0	0

Quick note: For those looking for Week 14 scores, they are below this post.

As some of you noticed, there was quite a delay in getting some of the scores posted prior to Week 14 play. While the IT Nerd being on vacation and not having his normal laptop with him were factors, they weren’t the main reason. The main reason was that there was a bug in the quota calculation formula. The bug was found immediately prior to the start of play for Week 13.

How the bug was found:

An early make-up between Jon Carroll and Mike Costello on 7/20 was submitted and they requested their updated quotas. Most times, I just enter them into the tracker and let it do the work. For whatever reason, I did them by hand…and they weren’t matching to what the sheet was calculating.

I also noticed something odd in the quota calculation for Mike Costello. The quota formula was returning an “#N/A” for a round that I know Mike had played. Below is an example. At that point, Mike had played 12 rounds in 2023 and the formula found his 11th round score, 9th round score, 8th round and 7th round (5 rounds). You can see that his 10th round was unable to be found, thus producing an “#N/A” (error) and an error in the overall formula (last column is supposed to be the result).

What caused the bug:

The short answer is double matches and our approach to them this year as well as the capability to play any matches throughout the year.

Each round a player completes is timestamped by date and time (Date Played column). The “P count” column (short for “Played Count”) is there to determine the sequence in which those matches were played. In order to determine that order, the sheet using a “RANK.EQ” formula which ranks those dates from earliest to latest. Mike Costello played his first round on 4/27 at 5 pm, second round on 5/11 at 5 pm, etc., etc.

In the past, when there were double matches, one match would be timestamped at say 17:00 while the second would be timestamped at 17:01 after they were entered so that the quota would remain the same for that double match. When the quota calculation would run for the following week, it would see two scores in very rapid succession and factor them both in for quota calculation despite the fact that it was only one actual round of golf.

This year, the change was made to timestamp them at the same time to avoid that double counting. Unknown to the IT Nerd, when the RANK.EQ formula runs and sees two results at the same time, it calls them a draw. You can see an example of that in the above. Note Mike Costello’s round 8 was played 7/6 at 15:00 (early round), then his 9th round was a double match on 7/6 at 17:00 (normal time). Note that there are two “9th rounds” and no 10th round.

Bringing back to Mike Costello’s quota calculation:

The bottom row of it asks what is the highest number of rounds someone has played for the year. In Mike’s case, it’s 12. It then simply subtracts 1 (resulting in 11), subtracts 2 (resulting in 10), etc., etc. until we get all 6 rounds. Prior to this year, all rounds had to be completed in sequential order and prior to the next weeks play. Therefore, the “max round count minus 1, then minus 2, etc…” would work.

Note that because there was a tie on the timestamp for his 9th rounds, the formula doesn’t produce a 10th round…it just goes right to 11. When the formula tries to find what Mike shot for his 10th round, there is no tenth round, so it returns error. Since there is an error in one cell of the formula, the entire formula returned an error.

An informed excel user might then ask the question: If the quota formula was producing an error, how was it that it wasn’t really caught until later on? Wouldn’t people have received “errors” for handicaps earlier?

The IT Nerd’s response is simple: That formula error is common for people who do not yet have 6 rounds like someone who is new to the league. When it sees that error, it thinks the person is new and doesn’t have the necessary rounds for a quota adjustment and returns back the quota that the person started with. Hence, it wouldn’t produce an error, but it might produce an incorrect quota.

How do we know who this could have impacted?

Key word there is could have impacted. The easy way to find out who could have been impacted was to look to see who also has that error in their quota calculation. At that time, it was found that there were twelve (12) golfers who could have been impacted.

At the conclusion of play on Week 13, the IT Nerd met with the TBO Board to seek direction: Do we go back and make the quotas accurate on matches that have already been played only weeks ago or do we let the past be what it is an move forward with the corrections?

The decision of the Board was to have accurate quotas and adjust any matches to reflect what the quotas should have been. There’s more detail later on in the post, but only 3 golfers were actually impacted and it did not impact the other 9.

How were the impacts assessed?

For those who played a double match, their quotas were only impacted after they played the double match. The IT Nerd then went back in time for each of the impacted golfers and hand calculated what the quotas should have been for each match, what impact that had on the match (if at all) and make the adjustments. Below is a screenshot of the hand calculations for one of the impacted golfers, Jon Carroll. Jon was particularly impacted because his first double match was much earlier and had more of them.

Who was actually impacted?

After all of the hand calculations, only three golfers were impacted in terms of wins-losses-draws:

1. Jon Carroll
   • Week 11 match vs. Costello – Jon’s quota on the card was listed as an 8, but he should have been a 10. On the card, Jon beat Costello by 1 point. With Jon’s quota shifting from the incorrect 8 to the correct 10, that becomes a loss for Jon and a win for Costello.
   • Week 12 match vs. Mike Mahar – Incorrect Quotas on the card had Jon at an 8 and Mike at a 7. The correct quotas were Jon as a 10 and Mike Mahar as a 5. On the incorrect quotas, Jon won by 4. With Jon’s quota going up 2 and Mike’s going down 2, that turns that match to a tie.
2. Mike Mahar
   • Week 12 match vs. Jon Carroll mentioned above – Was a loss based on incorrect quotas, now is a tie.
   • Week 11 match vs. Brian Thayer – Mike was listed as a 7 and should have been a 5. On the card, he lost the match to Thayer by 1 point. With the adjustment from an incorrect 7 down to a correct 5, Mike now wins the match.
3. Marty Donegan
   • Week 7 match vs. Rob Manipole – Marty was incorrectly listed as a 9 and his quota should have been a 10. Based on the incorrect card, Marty won that match by 1 point. When the correct quota is applied, it becomes a tie between Marty and Manipole.

The other 9 golfers who had no impacts to their wins-draws-losses were Rob Manipole, Tom Donegan, Mike Costello (aside from the impacts from Jon’s match), Joe Donegan, Bill Kirkby, Dan Keeley, Jim Morgan, Mike Shanahan, John Mooney.

What fixes were put in place and how do we know it worked?

The fix came in two steps:

The first step was to avoid the ‘tie’ in the rankings. I repurposed the next column over to run a second check on the “P Count” column. When it sees the second instance of a round at the same time, it returns a blank space. You can see the formula in action below for Mike Costello’s second instance of his 9th round.

The second step was to replace the “max rounds minus 1, minus 2, etc.” formula. The IT Nerd needed a formula which would automatically pick the latest round, second latest round, etc., until it picked up the last 6 rounds. Perfect function for this is the LARGE function within excel and to have it reference the newly created “Date Counts” field which eliminates the draws. Example of the formula in action is below. You can see it jump from Round 11 to Round 9 because there is no Round 10 (at least, in the formulas).

With the formulas working, they were replicated across the entire league and have been verified to be functioning properly.

Apologies on the length, but this is the stuff the IT Nerd loves talking about!!

Players have until the end of play on Week 15 (August 3rd) to complete any outstanding makeups. Regardless of the story, any unplayed matches will be recorded as a 1-1 draw.

Flight 1	Flight 2	Flight 3
Devin Carrigan – 1	Ed Van Slyke – 1	John Mooney – 0
Connor Brown – 0	Drew Prucha – 0	Mike Burns – 3
Dan Kane – 3	Rick Fanto – 0	Marty Donegan – 1
Pat Donahue – 4	Chris Donegan – 0	Jon Carroll – 1
Mike Carroll – 1	Dale Russell – 1	Bill Kirkby – 0
TJ Donegan – 2	Dan Keeley – 0	Mike Costello – 0
Merritt Daniels – 0	Sean Mott – 1	Rob Manipole – 1
DJ Mahar – 0	Jim Morgan – 0	Brian Thayer – 0
Steve Donegan – 0	Denny Welch – 0	Mike Mahar – 0
Dick Donegan – 0	Mike Shanahan – 1	Tom Donegan – 0
Craig Hawkinson – 0	Dan Mahar – 0	Bob Moran – 0
Matt Lochner – 1	Paul Daniels – 0	Joe Donegan – 0

Outstanding Makeups

• Week 2 (Back)
  • Pat Donahue v. TJ Donegan
  • Ed Van Slyke v. Dale Russell
  • Marty Donegan v. Mike Burns
• Week 5 (Front)
  • Pat Donahue v. Matt Lochner
• Week 8 (Back)
  • Devin Carrigan v. Dan Kane
• Week 9 (Front)
  • Dan Kane v. Pat Donahue
• Week 11 (Front)
  • Pat Donahue v. TJ Donegan
• Week 12 (Back)
  • Mike Burns v. Rob Manipole
• Week 13 (Front)
  • Mike Shanahan v. Sean Mott
• Week 14 (Back)
  • Dan Kane v. Mike Carroll
  • Mike Burns v. Jon Carroll

REMINDER THAT MAKE-UPS ARE DUE BY THE END OF PLAY ON WEEK 15, 8/5.

Subsequent post will outline the remaining matches outstanding

Flight 1			Flight 3
Devin Carrigan	BIR#17	$              18	John Mooney	BIR#13	$                   7
Connor Brown		$              –	Mike Burns	PAR#10	$                   7
Dan Kane		$              –	Marty Donegan	BIR#12PAR#17	$                 14
Pat Donahue		$              –	Jon Carroll		$                   –
Mike Carroll		$              –	Bill Kirkby		$                   –
TJ Donegan		$              –	Mike Costello		$                   –
Merritt Daniels		$              –	Rob Manipole		$                   –
DJ Mahar		$              –	Brian Thayer		$                   –
Steve Donegan		$              –	Mike Mahar	PAR#16	$                   7
Dick Donegan	BIR#13	$              18	Tom Donegan		$                   –
Craig Hawkinson		$              –	Bob Moran		$                   –
Matt Lochner		$              –	Joe Donegan		$                   –
Flight 2
Ed Van Slyke		$              –	Sean Mott	BIR#14	$                   9
Drew Prucha		$              –	Jim Morgan		$                   –
Rick Fanto		$              –	Denny Welch	PAR#18	$                   9
Chris Donegan		$              –	Mike Shanahan		$                   –
Dale Russell	PAR#10	$                9	Dan Mahar		$                   –
Dan Keeley	BIR#13	$                9	Paul Daniels		$                   –

Connor Brown Skin Pool:

Devin Carrigan		$             –
Connor Brown		$             –
Dan Kane		$             –
Pat Donahue		$             –
TJ Donegan		$             –
Merritt Daniels		$             –
DJ Mahar		$             –
Steve Donegan	BIR#14	$            65
Dick Donegan		$             –
Dale Russell		$             –
Dan Keeley		$             –
Paul Daniels		$             –
Mike Burns		$             –

		Week 15
TJ Donegan	12	VS	17	Connor Brown
Pat Donahue	12	VS	15	Mike Carroll
Devin Carrigan	16	VS	15	Dan Kane
Matt Lochner	12	VS	13	DJ Mahar
Dick Donegan	12	VS	11	Craig Hawkinson
Merritt Daniels	13	VS	11	Steve Donegan
Dan Keeley	12	VS	12	Drew Prucha
Chris Donegan	11	VS	10	Dale Russell
Ed Van Slyke	12	VS	11	Rick Fanto
Paul Daniels	11	VS	10	Jim Morgan
Mike Shanahan	10	VS	10	Dan Mahar
Sean Mott	11	VS	9	Denny Welch
Mike Costello	7	VS	9	Mike Burns
Jon Carroll	11	VS	7	Bill Kirkby
John Mooney	9	VS	8	Marty Donegan
Joe Donegan	9	VS	8	Brian Thayer
Tom Donegan	6	VS	8	Bob Moran
Rob Manipole	2	VS	4	Mike Mahar

Devin Carrigan	16	4	5	6	5	3	5	3	3	5	39	0	3
TJ Donegan	12	6	6	6	4	3	5	4	4	6	44	-2	0
Mike Mahar	4	8	7	8	4	3	5	3	5	9	52	3	3
Bill John	11	7	4	5	4	4	4	3	5	7	43	1	0
Ed Van Slyke	12	5	6	7	5	4	5	5	6	8	51	-8	0
Dan Keeley	13	5	6	5	3	4	5	5	3	9	45	0	3
Merritt Daniels	14	5	4	6	4	4	6	3	5	6	43	-3	0
Matt Lochner	11	5	4	5	4	2	5	3	5	6	39	5	3
Steve Donegan	11	5	6	6	5	2	4	6	4	8	46	-1	0
Craig Hawkinson	10	6	6	5	5	3	6	4	4	5	44	0	3
Rob Manipole	1	8	6	8	5	3	6	4	6	7	53	2	3
Joe Donegan	8	6	5	6	5	3	5	4	5	8	47	0	0
Brian Thayer	7	5	5	7	4	4	6	4	5	7	47	0	3
Tom Donegan	6	7	6	7	6	4	6	4	5	8	53	-3	0
Rick Fanto	10	5	5	7	4	4	5	3	3	6	42	3	0
Dale Russell	9	4	4	6	5	4	5	3	4	6	41	4	3
Connor Brown	16	4	4	5	4	3	4	4	4	4	36	3	1
Pat Donahue	12	4	4	5	4	3	5	3	5	6	39	3	1
DJ Mahar	12	7	4	5	5	3	4	3	4	4	39	5	3
Dick Donegan	12	6	6	5	3	3	4	5	4	6	42	1	0
Drew Prucha	13	5	5	7	4	4	5	4	4	6	44	-3	0
Chris Donegan	11	5	4	6	4	3	5	2	4	7	40	4	3
Denny Welch	9	5	6	5	5	3	6	2	5	5	42	4	3
Dan Mahar	10	5	5	5	4	4	4	4	4	7	42	2	0
John Mooney	9	7	6	7	3	5	5	4	6	6	49	-2	0
Mike Costello	6	6	5	7	5	4	5	4	6	6	48	0	3
Marty Donegan	8	5	5	4	4	3	5	4	4	7	41	6	3
Bill Kirkby	7	6	5	7	5	3	6	5	5	7	49	-2	0
Sean Mott	11	5	5	7	4	2	5	3	5	7	43	1	0
Paul Daniels	11	5	4	5	6	3	4	3	5	6	41	2	3
Jim Morgan	10	6	6	8	5	4	6	4	5	7	51	-6	0
Mike Shanahan	10	5	5	6	5	3	5	4	5	6	44	0	3

Apologies on the IT Nerd’s tardiness in posting, but he’s on vacation this week and experience multiple instances of technical failures. There will be no standings updates posted after Week 13 update, so will wait until after the Week 14 scores are entered to update standings.

To make the league aware, there was a formula issue identified in the quota calculation prior to the start of Week 13 play. The root cause of the issue has been found, formula corrections made. This means that Quotas for play during Week 13 were accurately calculated.

Flight 1			Flight 3
Devin Carrigan		$              –	John Mooney		$                   –
Connor Brown		$              –	Mike Burns		$                   –
Dan Kane		$              –	Marty Donegan		$                   –
Pat Donahue		$              –	Jon Carroll	BIR#1BIR#7	$                18
Mike Carroll		$              –	Bill Kirkby		$                   –
TJ Donegan		$              –	Mike Costello		$                   –
Merritt Daniels		$              –	Rob Manipole		$                   –
DJ Mahar		$              –	Brian Thayer		$                   –
Steve Donegan	BIR#7	$             36	Mike Mahar	PAR#4	$                  9
Dick Donegan		$              –	Tom Donegan	PAR#9	$                  9
Craig Hawkinson		$              –	Bob Moran		$                   –
Matt Lochner		$              –	Joe Donegan		$                   –
Flight 2
Ed Van Slyke	BIR#6	$               9	Sean Mott		$                   –
Drew Prucha		$              –	Jim Morgan	BIR#7	$                  9
Rick Fanto	PAR#9	$               9	Denny Welch		$                   –
Chris Donegan		$              –	Mike Shanahan		$                   –
Dale Russell		$              –	Dan Mahar		$                   –
Dan Keeley		$              –	Paul Daniels	BIR#8	$                  9

Connor Brown Skin Pool

Devin Carrigan		$             –
Connor Brown		$             –
Dan Kane		$             –
Pat Donahue		$             –
TJ Donegan		$             –
Merritt Daniels		$             –
DJ Mahar		$             –
Steve Donegan	BIR#7	$            32
Dick Donegan		$             –
Dale Russell		$             –
Dan Keeley		$             –
Paul Daniels	BIR#8	$            32
Mike Burns		$             –

		Week 14
Connor Brown	16	VS	12	Pat Donahue
Devin Carrigan	16	VS	12	TJ Donegan
Dan Kane	15	VS	15	Mike Carroll
DJ Mahar	12	VS	12	Dick Donegan
Merritt Daniels	14	VS	11	Matt Lochner
Steve Donegan	11	VS	10	Craig Hawkinson
Drew Prucha	12	VS	11	Chris Donegan
Ed Van Slyke	12	VS	13	Dan Keeley
Rick Fanto	10	VS	9	Dale Russell
Jim Morgan	10	VS	10	Mike Shanahan
Sean Mott	11	VS	11	Paul Daniels
Denny Welch	9	VS	10	Dan Mahar
Mike Burns	9	VS	11	Jon Carroll
John Mooney	9	VS	6	Mike Costello
Marty Donegan	8	VS	7	Bill Kirkby
Brian Thayer	7	VS	6	Tom Donegan
Rob Manipole	1	VS	8	Joe Donegan
Mike Mahar	4	VS	8	Bob Moran

Wk 13	Hole	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	Gross	Differential	Pts
Par		5	4	5	4	4	3	4	3	4
John Mooney	9	6	5	9	6	6	4	4	5	7	52	-4	0
Jon Carroll	10	4	6	6	5	5	5	3	5	7	46	1	3
Chris Donegan	11	6	5	6	5	5	3	5	4	7	46	-2	0
Ed Van Slyke	12	7	4	7	4	4	2	4	4	8	44	0	3
Bill Kirkby	7	6	6	7	5	4	4	4	4	5	45	2	3
Mike Burns	9	6	4	6	5	5	4	5	4	5	44	1	0
Mike Carroll	15	5	5	7	6	4	3	4	4	6	44	-5	3
Connor Brown	16	8	5	6	4	5	4	4	3	7	46	-6	0
Paul Daniels	11	5	6	8	4	5	5	5	2	5	45	0	3
Denny Welch	8	7	6	6	5	5	5	5	4	5	48	-2	0
Pat Donahue	12	4	7	7	4	4	4	4	3	6	43	1	3
Devin Carrigan	16	5	4	6	6	5	3	4	4	4	41	-3	0
Craig Hawkinson	10	5	4	7	7	4	5	6	3	5	46	-1	0
DJ Mahar	12	4	5	5	5	4	4	5	4	4	40	3	3
Dale Russell	9	6	5	5	4	4	3	5	4	5	41	4	0
Drew Prucha	11	5	4	6	4	4	3	4	3	5	38	5	3
Joe Donegan	7	5	5	6	6	5	4	4	4	6	45	2	3
Mike Mahar	4	7	7	7	4	7	4	6	5	6	53	-1	0
Dan Mahar	11	6	5	7	5	5	4	6	3	5	46	-3	0
Jim Morgan	10	5	4	9	5	4	4	3	4	5	43	4	3
Dick Donegan	12	4	5	7	5	6	4	4	4	6	45	-2	1
Merritt Daniels	14	5	4	6	7	4	4	4	3	6	43	-2	1
Bob Moran	7	6	5	7	5	6	4	5	4	7	49	-1	0
Brian Thayer	6	6	4	6	5	4	3	4	4	6	42	6	3
Mike Costello	7	6	6	7	7	4	5	6	3	6	50	-2	0
Marty Donegan	9	5	4	8	7	5	3	4	4	6	46	1	3
Dan Keeley	13	5	6	5	7	6	3	5	4	5	46	-4	0
Rick Fanto	10	6	5	9	5	5	5	5	3	4	47	-1	3
Gary Thompson	8	6	4	7	6	6	4	5	3	4	45	1	3
Dan Kane	15	5	5	5	5	4	4	6	4	5	43	-4	0
Tom Donegan	6	6	5	8	5	4	4	4	3	4	43	6	3
Rob Manipole	0										0	0	0
Steve Donegan		5	4	7	4	4	4	3	3	4

Player	Quota Perf	Pts	Total	Sub?
Devin Carrigan	-3	0	0
Connor Brown	-6	0	0
Dan Kane	-4	0	0
Pat Donahue	1	3	3
Mike Carroll	-5	3	3
Gary Thompson	1	3	3	X
Merritt Daniels	-2	1	1
DJ Mahar	3	3	3
Steve Donegan	DNP	DNP	0
Dick Donegan	-2	1	1
Craig Hawkinson	-1	0	0
Matt Lochner	DNP	DNP	0
Ed Van Slyke	0	3	3
Drew Prucha	5	3	3
Rick Fanto	-1	3	3
Chris Donegan	-2	0	0
Dale Russell	4	0	0
Dan Keeley	-4	0	0
Sean Mott	DNP	DNP	0
Jim Morgan	4	3	3
Denny Welch	-2	0	0
Mike Shanahan	DNP	DNP	0
Dan Mahar	-3	0	0
Paul Daniels	0	3	3
John Mooney	-4	0	0
Mike Burns	1	0	0
Marty Donegan	1	3	3
Jon Carroll	3	3	3
Bill Kirkby	2	3	3
Mike Costello	-2	0	0
Rob Manipole	0	0	0
Brian Thayer	6	3	3
Mike Mahar	-1	0	0
Tom Donegan	6	3	3
Bob Moran	-1	0	0
Joe Donegan	2	3	3

As most of you recall, El Commish has given us hackers until the end of play on Week 15 to have all of our matches completed.

A few important notes about make-ups:

• If a card is not received by end of play on Week 15, it will count as a 1-1 draw regardless of the story.
• Your quota for a make-up is what the quota is at that time, which is based on your last 6 matches played (regardless of what week it was).
• When a make-up is played, send the card to El Commish or the IT Nerd so it can be recorded timely.
• To give you a sense of where the league is at, we’ve only completed two of the ten weeks played so far (Weeks 6 and 7).
• Start making a plan to play these matches – For those planning on playing doubles, there is one attempt left on the Back (Wk 14), two attempts left on the front (Wk 13, 15)

People with outstanding Make-ups and the number of makeups outstanding:

Flight 1	Flight 2	Flight 3
Devin Carrigan – 3	Ed Van Slyke – 1	John Mooney – 0
Connor Brown – 2	Drew Prucha – 3	Mike Burns – 2
Dan Kane – 2	Rick Fanto – 2	Marty Donegan – 2
Pat Donahue – 4	Chris Donegan – 0	Jon Carroll – 2
Mike Carroll – 0	Dale Russell – 4	Bill Kirkby – 0
TJ Donegan – 2	Dan Keeley – 2	Mike Costello – 1
Merritt Daniels – 0	Sean Mott – 1	Rob Manipole – 2
DJ Mahar – 2	Jim Morgan – 0	Brian Thayer – 0
Steve Donegan – 0	Denny Welch – 0	Mike Mahar – 0
Dickie Donegan – 0	Mike Shanahan – 1	Tom Donegan – 2
Craig Hawkinson – 2	Dan Mahar – 0	Bob Moran – 2
Matt Lochner – 3	Paul Daniels – 2	Joe Donegan – 1

Flight 1			Flight 3
Devin Carrigan	BIR#17BIR#18	$             14	John Mooney		$                   –
Connor Brown		$              –	Mike Burns		$                   –
Dan Kane	BIR#15	$               7	Marty Donegan		$                   –
Pat Donahue		$              –	Jon Carroll	PAR#10	$                18
Mike Carroll		$              –	Bill Kirkby		$                   –
TJ Donegan		$              –	Mike Costello		$                   –
Merritt Daniels	BIR#14	$               7	Rob Manipole		$                   –
DJ Mahar		$              –	Brian Thayer		$                   –
Steve Donegan		$              –	Mike Mahar	PAR#17	$                18
Dick Donegan		$              –	Tom Donegan		$                   –
Craig Hawkinson		$              –	Bob Moran		$                   –
Matt Lochner	BIR#11	$               7	Joe Donegan		$                   –
Flight 2
Ed Van Slyke	BIR#18	$             18	Sean Mott		$                   –
Drew Prucha		$              –	Jim Morgan		$                   –
Rick Fanto		$              –	Denny Welch		$                   –
Chris Donegan		$              –	Mike Shanahan		$                   –
Dale Russell		$              –	Dan Mahar	BIR#13	$                18
Dan Keeley		$              –	Paul Daniels		$                   –

Connor Brown Skin Pool

Devin Carrigan	BIR#17BIR#18	$            26
Connor Brown		$             –
Dan Kane	BIR#15	$            13
Pat Donahue		$             –
TJ Donegan		$             –
Merritt Daniels	BIR#14	$            13
DJ Mahar		$             –
Steve Donegan		$             –
Dick Donegan		$             –
Dale Russell		$             –
Dan Keeley	BIR#11	$            13
Paul Daniels		$             –
Mike Burns		$             –

		Week 13
TJ Donegan	12	VS	15	Dan Kane
Pat Donahue	12	VS	16	Devin Carrigan
Mike Carroll	15	VS	16	Connor Brown
Matt Lochner	11	VS	11	Steve Donegan
Dick Donegan	12	VS	14	Merritt Daniels
Craig Hawkinson	10	VS	13	DJ Mahar
Dan Keeley	13	VS	10	Rick Fanto
Chris Donegan	11	VS	12	Ed Van Slyke
Dale Russell	9	VS	11	Drew Prucha
Paul Daniels	11	VS	8	Denny Welch
Mike Shanahan	11	VS	10	Sean Mott
Dan Mahar	11	VS	10	Jim Morgan
Mike Costello	11	VS	9	Marty Donegan
Jon Carroll	8	VS	9	John Mooney
Bill Kirkby	6	VS	9	Mike Burns
Joe Donegan	6	VS	7	Mike Mahar
Tom Donegan	6	VS	3	Rob Manipole
Bob Moran	7	VS	6	Brian Thayer

Wk 12	Hole	10	11	12	13	14	15	16	17	18	Gross	Differential	Pts
Par		4	4	5	4	3	4	3	4	5
John Mooney	9	5	4	6	5	4	5	3	8	7	47	-1	0
Joe Donegan	5	6	5	5	5	3	4	5	7	7	47	3	3
Rick Fanto	9	4	5	5	5	3	7	3	5	7	44	2	0
Jim Morgan	10	4	3	5	4	4	5	3	5	9	42	5	3
Jon Carroll	8	4	4	7	4	6	4	3	5	6	43	3	3
Mike Mahar	7	6	6	6	5	4	7	3	4	10	51	-1	0
Mike Costello	7	6	5	5	4	3	5	3	6	7	44	3	3
Bob Moran	7	6	7	6	4	5	5	4	5	7	49	-1	0
TJ Donegan	12	5	4	6	4	4	6	4	5	5	43	-1	0
Craig Hawkinson	10	4	5	5	4	4	7	3	4	7	43	2	3
Bill Kirkby	6	5	5	5	5	3	6	5	5	7	46	2	3
Tom Donegan	6	5	5	6	7	4	5	4	5	9	50	1	0
Chris Donegan	11	6	5	6	4	3	5	4	5	6	44	-1	3
Denny Welch	9	8	6	7	4	4	6	4	5	7	51	-5	0
Marty Donegan	9	5	7	7	6	3	5	3	5	9	50	-2	0
Brian Thayer	6	6	5	7	5	4	5	3	5	6	46	2	3
Pat Donahue	13	4	5	5	6	4	5	3	6	9	47	-4	0
Steve Donegan	12	5	5	6	4	3	5	3	8	6	45	-2	3
Ed Van Slyke	11	4	4	5	4	3	4	3	4	4	35	9	3
Paul Daniels	12	4	6	9	5	4	5	4	4	8	49	-4	0
Dan Keeley	11	4	3	6	5	4	5	3	5	5	40	4	3
Dan Mahar	11	5	5	6	3	4	4	6	5	6	44	0	0
Devin Carrigan	16	6	5	5	4	4	4	3	3	4	38	2	0
Matt Lochner	11	5	3	5	4	3	4	3	5	7	39	5	3
Dan Kane	14	3	6	5	3	3	3	3	4	5	35	8	3
DJ Mahar	13	4	4	6	4	4	6	3	7	6	44	-2	0
Connor Brown	16	3	4	6	3	5	5	4	4	5	39	1	0
Merritt Daniels	13	4	5	6	3	2	5	4	4	5	38	5	3
Mike Carroll	15	4	5	5	4	3	5	3	4	4	37	3	3
Dick Donegan	13	6	6	6	4	4	5	4	4	4	43	-1	0

Team	Player	Quota Perf	Pts	Total
1	Devin Carrigan	2	0	0
2	Connor Brown	1	0	0
3	Dan Kane	7	3	3
4	Pat Donahue	-3	0	0
5	Mike Carroll	3	3	3
6	TJ Donegan	-1	0	0
7	Merritt Daniels	4	3	3
8	DJ Mahar	-2	0	0
9	Steve Donegan	-1	3	3
10	Dick Donegan	-1	0	0
11	Craig Hawkinson	2	3	3
12	Matt Lochner	5	3	3
13	Ed Van Slyke	8	3	3
14	Drew Prucha	DNP	DNP	0
15	Rick Fanto	1	0	0
16	Chris Donegan	-1	3	3
17	Dale Russell	DNP	DNP	0
18	Dan Keeley	2	3	3
19	Sean Mott	DNP	DNP	0
20	Jim Morgan	5	3	3
21	Denny Welch	-4	0	0
22	Mike Shanahan	DNP	DNP	0
23	Dan Mahar	0	0	0
24	Paul Daniels	-3	0	0
25	John Mooney	-1	0	0
26	Mike Burns	DNP	DNP	0
27	Marty Donegan	-2	0	0
28	Jon Carroll	3	3	3
29	Bill Kirkby	2	3	3
30	Mike Costello	-1	1	1
31	Rob Manipole	DNP	DNP	0
32	Brian Thayer	2	3	3
33	Mike Mahar	-1	0	0
34	Tom Donegan	1	0	0
35	Bob Moran	-1	1	1
36	Joe Donegan	3	3	3

League completed 3 makeups last week, but 3 more got added to the list with three matches left open from Week 11.

Flight 1			Flight 3
Devin Carrigan	BIR#3	$                7	John Mooney		$                   –
Connor Brown		$              –	Mike Burns		$                   –
Dan Kane		$              –	Marty Donegan		$                   –
Pat Donahue	BIR#2	$              7	Jon Carroll	BIR#1BOG#3	$                 24
Mike Carroll	BIR#5BIR#7BIR#9	$              21	Bill Kirkby		$                   –
TJ Donegan		$              –	Mike Costello		$                   –
Merritt Daniels		$              –	Rob Manipole		$                   –
DJ Mahar		$              –	Brian Thayer		$                   –
Steve Donegan		$              –	Mike Mahar	BIR#5	$                 12
Dick Donegan		$              –	Tom Donegan		$                   –
Craig Hawkinson		$              –	Bob Moran		$                   –
Matt Lochner		$              –	Joe Donegan		$                   –
Flight 2
Ed Van Slyke	BIR#2BIR#7	$              24	Sean Mott		$                   –
Drew Prucha		$              –	Jim Morgan		$                   –
Rick Fanto		$              –	Denny Welch		$                   –
Chris Donegan		$              –	Mike Shanahan		$                   –
Dale Russell	PAR#9	$              12	Dan Mahar		$                   –
Dan Keeley		$              –	Paul Daniels		$                   –

Connor Brown Skin Pool

Devin Carrigan	BIR#3	$            32
Connor Brown		$             –
Dan Kane		$             –
Pat Donahue		$             –
TJ Donegan		$             –
Merritt Daniels		$             –
DJ Mahar		$             –
Steve Donegan		$             –
Dick Donegan		$             –
Dale Russell		$             –
Dan Keeley	BIR#5	$            32
Paul Daniels		$             –
Mike Burns		$             –

		Week 12
Devin Carrigan	16	VS	11	Matt Lochner
Connor Brown	16	VS	13	Merritt Daniels
Dan Kane	14	VS	14	DJ Mahar
Pat Donahue	13	VS	12	Steve Donegan
Mike Carroll	15	VS	13	Dick Donegan
TJ Donegan	12	VS	10	Craig Hawkinson
Ed Van Slyke	11	VS	12	Paul Daniels
Drew Prucha	11	VS	10	Sean Mott
Rick Fanto	9	VS	10	Jim Morgan
Chris Donegan	11	VS	10	Denny Welch
Dale Russell	9	VS	11	Mike Shanahan
Dan Keeley	11	VS	11	Dan Mahar
John Mooney	9	VS	6	Joe Donegan
Mike Burns	9	VS	3	Rob Manipole
Marty Donegan	9	VS	6	Brian Thayer
Jon Carroll	8	VS	7	Mike Mahar
Bill Kirkby	6	VS	6	Tom Donegan
Mike Costello	7	VS	7	Bob Moran

		Week 12
Devin Carrigan	16	VS	11	Matt Lochner
Connor Brown	16	VS	13	Merritt Daniels
Dan Kane	14	VS	14	DJ Mahar
Pat Donahue	13	VS	12	Steve Donegan
Mike Carroll	15	VS	13	Dick Donegan
TJ Donegan	12	VS	10	Craig Hawkinson
Ed Van Slyke	11	VS	12	Paul Daniels
Drew Prucha	11	VS	10	Sean Mott
Rick Fanto	9	VS	10	Jim Morgan
Chris Donegan	11	VS	10	Denny Welch
Dale Russell	9	VS	11	Mike Shanahan
Dan Keeley	11	VS	11	Dan Mahar
John Mooney	9	VS	6	Joe Donegan
Mike Burns	9	VS	3	Rob Manipole
Marty Donegan	9	VS	6	Brian Thayer
Jon Carroll	8	VS	7	Mike Mahar
Bill Kirkby	6	VS	6	Tom Donegan
Mike Costello	7	VS	7	Bob Moran

Wk 11	Hole	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	Gross	Differential	Pts
Par		5	4	5	4	4	3	4	3	4
Denny Welch	8	6	5	6	4	5	4	5	3	5	43	3	1
Jim Morgan	10	5	4	6	5	3	4	4	5	6	42	3	1
Steve Donegan	12	7	4	7	5	4	3	5	3	5	43	-1	3
DJ Mahar	14	5	6	8	4	5	3	5	4	6	46	-5	0
Devin Carrigan	16	6	4	4	4	4	4	4	3	4	37	2	0
Mike Carroll	14	5	4	7	6	3	4	3	3	3	38	5	3
Rob Manipole	2	7	6	8	6	6	4	5	5	8	55	-1	0
Bob Moran	7	8	6	8	5	5	5	4	3	5	49	0	3
Tom Donegan	6	6	5	8	4	6	4	6	5	7	51	-1	0
Joe Donegan	6	6	5	7	4	5	5	3	3	6	44	5	3
Matt Lochner	11	6	4	7	6	4	4	5	3	7	46	-2	1
Dick Donegan	13	5	5	5	5	4	4	6	3	6	43	-2	1
Sean Mott	10	6	4	8	4	5	5	4	4	5	45	0	3
Dan Mahar	12	7	4	8	7	5	4	4	3	8	50	-5	0
Paul Daniels	11	6	4	7	4	5	4	4	3	6	43	0	3
Mike Shanahan	11	6	5	6	6	5	4	5	3	6	46	-3	0
Mike Costello	6	5	5	9	5	5	4	5	4	7	49	2	0
Jon Carroll	8	4	6	6	5	5	5	3	5	7	46	3	3
Mike Burns	9	6	5	10	7	6	4	6	3	6	53	-5	0
Marty Donegan	9	7	5	8	7	4	4	5	4	5	49	-2	3
Ed Van Slyke	10	6	3	6	5	4	4	3	4	5	40	6	3
Dale Russell	10	6	4	8	7	4	5	7	4	4	49	-2	0
Merritt Daniels	13	7	4	6	4	4	4	5	3	4	41	0	1
Craig Hawkinson	10	6	4	6	5	6	3	5	3	6	44	0	1
Mike Mahar	7	9	6	7	6	3	5	5	5	6	52	-2	0
Brian Thayer	7	9	5	8	4	5	5	5	4	6	51	-1	3
Dan Keeley	11	5	5	7	5	3	4	5	4	6	44	0	3
Chris Donegan	12	6	4	7	5	5	4	4	4	5	44	-2	0
John Mooney	9	6	5	9	6	6	4	4	5	7	52	-4	0
Bill Kirkby	6	7	6	9	7	4	4	5	5	7	54	-2	3

Player	Quota Perf	Pts	Total
Devin Carrigan	2	0	0
Connor Brown	DNP	DNP	0
Dan Kane	DNP	DNP	0
Pat Donahue	DNP	DNP	0
Mike Carroll	5	3	3
TJ Donegan	DNP	DNP	0
Merritt Daniels	0	1	1
DJ Mahar	-5	0	0
Steve Donegan	-1	3	3
Dick Donegan	-2	1	1
Craig Hawkinson	0	1	1
Matt Lochner	-2	1	1
Ed Van Slyke	6	3	3
Drew Prucha	DNP	DNP	0
Rick Fanto	DNP	DNP	0
Chris Donegan	-2	0	0
Dale Russell	-2	0	0
Dan Keeley	0	3	3
Sean Mott	0	3	3
Jim Morgan	3	1	1
Denny Welch	3	1	1
Mike Shanahan	-3	0	0
Dan Mahar	-5	0	0
Paul Daniels	0	3	3
John Mooney	-4	0	0
Mike Burns	-5	0	0
Marty Donegan	-2	3	3
Jon Carroll	3	3	3
Bill Kirkby	-2	3	3
Mike Costello	2	0	0
Rob Manipole	-1	0	0
Brian Thayer	-1	3	3
Mike Mahar	-2	0	0
Tom Donegan	-1	0	0
Bob Moran	0	3	3
Joe Donegan	5	3	3

As most of you recall, El Commish has given us hackers until the end of play on Week 15 to have all of our matches completed.

A few important notes about make-ups:

• If a card is not received by end of play on Week 15, it will count as a 1-1 draw regardless of the story.
• Your quota for a make-up is what the quota is at that time, which is based on your last 6 matches played (regardless of what week it was).
• When a make-up is played, send the card to El Commish or the IT Nerd so it can be recorded timely.
• To give you a sense of where the league is at, we’ve only completed two of the ten weeks played so far (Weeks 6 and 7).
• Start making a plan to play these matches – you’ve got roughly a month until they need to be completed

People with outstanding Make-ups and the number of makeups outstanding:

Flight 1	Flight 2	Flight 3
Devin Carrigan – 3	Ed Van Slyke – 1	John Mooney – 0
Connor Brown – 2	Drew Prucha – 1	Mike Burns – 2
Dan Kane – 3	Rick Fanto – 1	Marty Donegan – 2
Pat Donahue – 3	Chris Donegan – 0	Jon Carroll – 2
Mike Carroll – 1	Dale Russell – 3	Bill Kirkby – 1
TJ Donegan – 1	Dan Keeley – 3	Mike Costello – 3
Merritt Daniels – 0	Sean Mott – 1	Rob Manipole – 2
DJ Mahar – 2	Jim Morgan – 1	Brian Thayer – 0
Steve Donegan – 2	Denny Welch – 1	Mike Mahar – 1
Dickie Donegan – 0	Mike Shanahan – 0	Tom Donegan – 2
Craig Hawkinson – 2	Dan Mahar – 0	Bob Moran – 2
Matt Lochner – 3	Paul Daniels – 2	Joe Donegan – 1